Sunday, January 23, 2011

TOC strengthens its resolve in the face of gazetting

The Online Citizen website has affirmed that it would not be intimidated by the recent action of the authorities in gazetting them as a political association or being required to register with the Media Development Authority (MDA).


In a statement entitled “Keep Calm and Carry On” released today at 1800hrs, TOC said they have been completely above board in their operations, and that they have nothing to hide nor fear from being gazetted. TOC added that “shutting down or going underground is precisely what those who misunderstand us want”, and they will not give them that satisfaction.


TOC has also written to the Prime Minister’s Office seeking a clarification on why it is being gazetted as a political association. In an open letter published together with their press release, TOC said that they “do not engage in partisan politics, and have no interest in engaging in partisan politics”.


They also added that “TOC is political to the extent and in the exact same way that all ordinary Singaporeans are political: by being interested in, and talking about, political issues that impact us and our country”.


As such TOC believes that being gazetted as a political association on the basis that it is “an organization whose objects or activities relate wholly or mainly to politics in Singapore” in unreasonable, and they asked the PM to reconsider his decision.


TOC also affirmed that they have never received foreign donations, and never intend to, and as such, have nothing to fear from being gazetted as a political association. Nonetheless, TOC has chosen to raise the objection as it feels that the threat that bloggers face in being gazetted “will have significant chilling effect on free expression in Singapore“.


Pending the outcome of TOC’s appeal to PMO to reverse the gazetting decision, TOC also said in a letter to MDA that they would, for now, not be sending MDA any information.


I personally believe The Online Citizen has handled the matter very professionally. They clearly understand the significance and implications of being gazetted as a political association, and have articulated why they feel it is an unfair move by the authorities.


But one thing stands clear: TOC is not afraid of being gazetted as it has already remained open and transparent, and has never availed itself to foreign funding. All their editors long ago have revealed their identities, and they are also likely to be prepared to put their names down on record and be held collectively responsible for TOC in the legal front.


In fact, on the issue of foreign funding, it is the government that has been hypocritical. Our government through its investment arms have regularly interfered in the domestic politics of other countries.


In fact, Singapore’s Government-Linked Corporations (GLCs) have even funded Australia’s political parties: see here. This is very shameful.


The government has enacted laws that seeks to intimidate its citizens and curtail freedom of speech. However, some people would not be intimidated or curtailed in such a cowardly manner. Only those who live in the shadows and attack other people behind a veil of anonymity should be afraid of the glare of sunlight. TOC has absolutely nothing to fear indeed.


View the original article here

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Idealism of Youths Needs to be Encouraged

 


Who is Kenneth Lin? Well, he is a boy who has just turned 16. He is also a smart lad who was recently given a scholarship at a grassroots scholarship award presentation. After the ceremony when the crowd had thinned out, Kenneth approached the Guest-of-Honour, a minister, to have a chat with him.


The conversation started cordially about what Kenneth did in school. Then Kenneth started asking difficult political questions. The conversation ended amicably but the parting of ways left a sour taste in the mouth after Kenneth was asked if he had recorded the conversation on his handphone and whether he was a member of a political party.


After reading the conversation recounted by Kenneth, I could not help but be reminded of the story of David and Goliath.


Like Kenneth the choirboy, David also used to sing and even founded the Temple of Singing. Like David, Kenneth does not appear to be intimidated by more important or powerful people.


The Idealism of Youth


I can understand Kenneth because, like him when I was young, I used to approach ministers whenever I got the opportunity and engage them on political issues. To me, 16-year-old Kenneth is probably just an idealist trying to look for a perfect society.


This type of idealism may be an anomaly in today’s Singapore but in the 50s and 60s, it was not uncommon for a fifteen year-old to be interested in politics. Singapore would not have got its independence without the idealism of its youths then.


There is, therefore, nothing wrong for a young boy to be idealistic. They should be. In fact, this is what is sorely lacking in Singapore’s youths today. Instead of frowning on the likes of Kenneth Lin, Singapore would do well to have more young people like him instead of having those who run around killing each other, posting their sexual escapades on the internet, taking pictures of female underwear and getting all the A’s in school while being oblivious to society’s problems.


Young people are naturally full or dreams and idealism. If Singapore’s youths are stifled to the extent that they are no longer idealistic or are afraid to share their dreams, then this country, as a nation, is going to be in serious trouble in future.


Thus a young person should be encouraged to speak his mind and have his questions answered instead of getting them brushed aside. In this age and time, we should try to eradicate the climate of fear and replace it with a more conducive environment for youths to develop a more enquiring mind.


I do not understand, therefore, why a meeting between a young boy and a minister should start so well and end up in such an unhappy confrontation.


I do not understand because it did not happen to me when I was young.


The Older Politicians


The Old Guard ministers that I had met were not condescending even though the style of their government at that time was certainly much more intimidating. They did not avoid thorny political questions. In fact you could see their face light up when political issues were brought up. If they did not agree with you, they would try to show why your premise was wrong, sometimes even with facts that could not be published in the press.


At no time did they appear to be worried that I would record our conversations (they did not ask if I had a tape recorder on me) nor did I care if anyone else had been covertly recording what had been said.


Even when I became an active Opposition politician, MPs like Dr Tan Cheng Bock, Tan Soo Khoon and some others felt comfortable talking to me. To these people, belonging to another political party does not make a person any lesser a Singaporean.


Only just last night I met a minister at a function. After we shook hands, he asked what I was doing now. I told him I am cultivating some young people. He told me that is a good thing to do. We need more young people coming forward. It would be good for Singapore.


There were no bodyguards staring at me. There was no sour ending. Kenneth would certainly have benefited from such an encounter.


It would, therefore, be good for political newbies to learn from these political veterans. Political affiliations should not devalue the merits of a political debate. In fact, diversity will enrich such a discourse.


Political leaders must know that their plans for the country are not the necessary the only workable solutions. Once they can realize this, they will be able to accept criticisms as positive feedback.


Wisdom From The Past


One exemplary leader that they can learn from is Duke Huan of the State of Qi.


Duke Huan of Qi (???) had a half-brother called Jiu. Each had a mentor to groom them to take over the throne. Duke Huan’s teacher was Bao Shuya (???) and his brother’s tutor was Guan Zhong(??).


When their father Duke Xiang was killed and the usurpers of the throne were in turned murdered, a vacuum was created. At that time Duke Huan was in the State of Ju and Jiu was in the State of Lu. Both brothers then led their men and raced back to Qi to try and claim the throne.


As State of Ju was nearer State of Qi, it was likely that Duke Huan would reach Qi first. Guan Zhong, Jiu’s mentor, decided to intercept Duke Huan before he reached Qi. Just outside the city, he met the Duke’s entourage, took out his bow and shot an arrow at the Duke.


As Duke Huan was wearing an armour at that time, this did not hurt him at all. Nevertheless he led out a loud cry and pretended to be dead. Satisfied, Guan Zhong rode away. Subsequently Duke Huan managed to arrive in Qi earlier than Jiu and took the throne and became the Marquis of Qi from 685 BC until his death.


After he came onto the throne, he demanded that Guan Zhong be extradited to Qi to be executed. When Guan Zhong was sent back to Qi, Duke Huan’s mentor, Bao Shuya, advised that the former be not put to death but be made the Prime Minister instead because he was such a talented person. Though Duke Huan was very unhappy at being nearly assassinated by Guan Zhong, he, nevertheless, took the advice and indeed, under the latter’s reforms, Qi became the strongest state of the time.


The moral of the story is to look at the positive side of a person.


The Young and The Future


The future of the country belongs to the young of today.


However, the young need to feel they belong and have a stake in this country. The political climate must, therefore, allow for the maximum development of intellect, the moral character and the creative energy of our youths.


The best guarantee of a good future for our country is the participation of a better-informed and educated young people.


Without such participation, we will only encourage bright young people to drop out of society, the talented to migrate and the majority to live their lives of apathy without any love or passion for their country.


Thus our youth, people like Kenneth, must be made to feel that there is a future and they have a hand in molding it. When we stifle idealism of young people, by refusing to engage them, we destroy their motivations, hopes and love for the country.


This is the meaning of being a true blue Singaporean.


Who then is this Kenneth? He is a true son of Singapore.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Gazetting group blogs as political associations is oppressive

 


Yesterday morning, The Online Citizen website announced that it had received an email sent by the Registry of Political Donations, under the PMO, stating that the Prime Minister intended to gazette it as a political association for the purposes of the Political Donations Act.


Then, in a late afternoon development, the Media Development Authority (MDA) informed TOC editors Choo Zheng Xi and Joshua Chiang that TOC has to be registered with the MDA “under condition 4 of the Schedule to the Broadcasting (Class License) Notification”, as MDA had deemed it to be a website that “providing a programme for the promotion or discussion of political issues relating to Singapore”.


My contention is that gazetting groups blogs such as TOC as political associations and requiring political bloggers to register with MDA would paradoxically lead to less transparency and less accountability over time, in contradiction with the stated purposes of the authorities.


As a gazetted political association, TOC would be barred from receiving funds from foreign donors, letting foreigners take part in its events, operating as a political party, and being affiliated to any local or foreign political party.


In my assessment, the majority of the above requirements should not affect TOC in any way, except possibly for:

not allowing foreigners to participate in events.

This is a gray area that afford the authorities too much administrative discretion and create a climate of uncertainty.


For example, while foreigners would still most likely be allowed to attend events organized by TOC at Speaker’s Corner or at indoor venues, they would presumably not be allowed to address the audience. Would they still be allowed to ask questions or carry placards? Would they still be allowed to wear a common attire?


There are no clear cut answers, and this is the evil of administrative discretion that makes being gazetted as a political association insidious.


The stated intent of being gazetted as a political association is to promote accountability and ensure no foreign funds are procured. In itself, this intent is noble, but unfortunately, the government has turned existing legislation into a double-edged sword that cuts also on the side of oppression.


Under the Political Donations Act, TOC would have to open its finances to scrutiny and report donations in excess of $5,000. While this is unlikely to impact TOC financially, TOC would face the same obstacles to fund raising as do current opposition parties. Ask any opposition party and they would readily testify that the Political Donations Act as it is currently structured makes it harder to raise funds through legal avenues. While foreign funding should logically be disallowed, there is a need to revamp the Political Donations Act so that it does not make it unfairly difficult for political entities to procure much-needed funds.


Being asked by the MDA to register under the Broadcasting (Class License) scheme is by itself no more than a cosmetic procedure that does not in any way change TOC’s current legal liability should it run afoul of the law in any way, such as by making defamatory remarks.


TOC’s owners and website administrators would have to reveal their full identities and details to MDA, but this should pose no problem as all of them are already prepared to identify themselves online.


However, this might have a disquieting effect on other political bloggers who do not wish to reveal so much to the authorities. There would be now be a greater incentive for bloggers to remain anonymous in order to avoid being asked by MDA to register under the Broadcasting (Class License) scheme. Paradoxically, this would lead to even less accountability and transparency from the blogosphere as a whole, contrary to what the authorities say they want to have.


Taking a step back, one can see that current legislation creates a climate of fear and allows the government to maintain control of sources of free speech and expression. There is a need to overhaul current legislation as well as restore democratic principles to our institutions.


The government’s approach thus far has been to use seemingly innocuous legislation to stifle constitutionally-legitimate avenues of speech and expression, while maintaining the semblance, but not the substance, of liberalization.


On the surface, gazetting group blogs and requiring registration with MDA seems justified, until one digs deeper and uncovers loopholes and layers of unjustified administrative discretion that serves the ruling party’s interest rather than the interests of citizens.


View the original article here

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

TOC strengthens its resolve in the face of gazetting

Written by Ng E-Jay
14 Jan 2011

The Online Citizen website has affirmed that it would not be intimidated by the recent action of the authorities in gazetting them as a political association or being required to register with the Media Development Authority (MDA).

In a statement entitled “Keep Calm and Carry On” released today at 1800hrs, TOC said they have been completely above board in their operations, and that they have nothing to hide nor fear from being gazetted. TOC added that “shutting down or going underground is precisely what those who misunderstand us want”, and they will not give them that satisfaction.

TOC has also written to the Prime Minister’s Office seeking a clarification on why it is being gazetted as a political association. In an open letter published together with their press release, TOC said that they “do not engage in partisan politics, and have no interest in engaging in partisan politics”.

They also added that “TOC is political to the extent and in the exact same way that all ordinary Singaporeans are political: by being interested in, and talking about, political issues that impact us and our country”.

As such TOC believes that being gazetted as a political association on the basis that it is “an organization whose objects or activities relate wholly or mainly to politics in Singapore” in unreasonable, and they asked the PM to reconsider his decision.

TOC also affirmed that they have never received foreign donations, and never intend to, and as such, have nothing to fear from being gazetted as a political association. Nonetheless, TOC has chosen to raise the objection as it feels that the threat that bloggers face in being gazetted “will have significant chilling effect on free expression in Singapore“.

Pending the outcome of TOC’s appeal to PMO to reverse the gazetting decision, TOC also said in a letter to MDA that they would, for now, not be sending MDA any information.

I personally believe The Online Citizen has handled the matter very professionally. They clearly understand the significance and implications of being gazetted as a political association, and have articulated why they feel it is an unfair move by the authorities.

But one thing stands clear: TOC is not afraid of being gazetted as it has already remained open and transparent, and has never availed itself to foreign funding. All their editors long ago have revealed their identities, and they are also likely to be prepared to put their names down on record and be held collectively responsible for TOC in the legal front.

In fact, on the issue of foreign funding, it is the government that has been hypocritical. Our government through its investment arms have regularly interfered in the domestic politics of other countries.

In fact, Singapore’s Government-Linked Corporations (GLCs) have even funded Australia’s political parties: see here. This is very shameful.

The government has enacted laws that seeks to intimidate its citizens and curtail freedom of speech. However, some people would not be intimidated or curtailed in such a cowardly manner. Only those who live in the shadows and attack other people behind a veil of anonymity should be afraid of the glare of sunlight. TOC has absolutely nothing to fear indeed.


View the original article here

Monday, January 17, 2011

PM wants TOC labelled as political association

 


Posted by The Online Citizen
Original link here.


The Prime Minister of Singapore has revealed his intentions to declare The Online Citizen as a political association.


According to an email sent to TOC at 5pm yesterday evening by the Prime Minister’s office, the Prime Minister  ”intends to declare the owners, editorial team, and administrators of The Online Citizen, by order in the Gazette, to be a political association for the purposes of the Political Donations Act. The owners, editorial team, and administrators of The Online Citizen have been determined to be an organization whose objects or activities relate wholly or mainly to politics in Singapore.”


This means that TOC is barred from receiving funds from foreign donors, letting foreigners take part in its events, operating as a political party and being affiliated to any local or foreign political party.


It is also not allowed to use its funds, premises and new media platforms in any election here, including the sponsoring of any candidate or member.


TOC has 14 days to reveal the identities of its owners, editorial team and administrators. TOC is also required to designate a President, Treasurer and Secretary of the association, and they will be responsible for the preparation and accuracy of the donations reports for The Online Citizen.


The last group to be gazetted is human rights advocacy NGO Maruah in November last year. Maruah is the fourth group -after the Open Singapore Centre, the Think Centre and Singaporeans For Democracy – to be gazetted as a political association.


If TOC complies, it will be the fifth. It will also be the first time bloggers are considered a political association.


View the original article here

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Desmond Lim engages lawyer to get response from SDA

CNA, 23 Dec 2010

SINGAPORE: The rift between Potong Pasir Member of Parliament Chiam See Tong and his former right-hand man Desmond Lim looks set to deepen, after the latter engaged a lawyer to defend him in disciplinary proceedings initiated against him.

Colin Ng & Partners’ Peter Low, a former Law Society president, will be representing Mr Lim. MediaCorp understands that a lawyer’s letter was sent to Mr Chiam on Wednesday.

On Dec 6, the Singapore People’ Party (SPP) central executive committee had sent Mr Lim a letter detailing nine charges against him, including the allegation that Mr Lim had made defamatory remarks about Mr Chiam in an October newspaper article over the issue of the Reform Party (RP) joining the Singapore Democratic Alliance (SDA).

The SPP, a component party of the SDA, was also unhappy with Mr Lim for speaking in his capacity as SDA secretary-general to the media.

Mr Lim, who had fended off an attempt by Mr Chiam to remove him from the SDA, responded to the charges the next day, but is still awaiting SPP’s replies.

Mr Lim told MediaCorp that he had “no choice but to engage a lawyer to formally ask them to respond to my letter”.

Said Mr Lim: “I’m taking this matter very seriously … It’s not that I want to get a lawyer to fight them. I also wish to find out who are the cadres in the disciplinary committee.”

MediaCorp understands that in his lawyer’s letter, Mr Lim pointed out that Mr Chiam should take him to court if he felt he was defamed, instead of subjecting Mr Lim to disciplinary proceedings.

Mr Chiam held a Christmas Party on Thursday, which was attended by several opposition leaders including RP chief Kenneth Jeyaretnam and the National Solidarity Party’s Sebastian Teo. When approached, Mr Chiam declined to comment on the lawyer’s letter.


View the original article here

Friday, January 14, 2011

TOC face to face forum: Meeting of Bodies but not of Minds

 


I went to the TOC Face to Face Forum as a guest of The Online Citizen and came away pleased and puzzled.


I was pleased to see the various political parties coming to share their views on the same stage. This is the first time that all the major parties are seen together at a single event. Except for the PAP who did not turn up and the Worker’s Party who sent a representative, all the secretary-generals of the invited parties honoured the occasion.


It was not a forum where the political parties make speeches about their stands on issues. It was a Q and A Session. However from the answers given, the listeners were able to know what the various parties stand for. From the answers given by the leaders of the various political parties, it was obvious that there were really not many differences in views and stands to the many issues that were brought up.


All the leaders agreed that the problems faced by Singaporeans had been brought about by the PAP and the people should vote for the opposition. In the past, speakers sometimes prefaced their speeches with some concession to the economic achievements of Singapore. Not this time around. No one credited the PAP with anything.


Why then did I say I come away puzzled? With so much in agreement and so little discernible differences, I was wondering, why no one embraced one another at the end of the evening and tell each other, “Hey we share the same views. Why don’t we meet up and see how we can work together to advance a common cause?”


Everyone just shook hands politely and smiled for group photographs. I don’t know if they were more pre-occupied about their own performance that they could not think of seizing the opportunity to strengthen ties that could be developed further for the benefit the country.


The forum had given them this golden opportunity. Yet during the post-forum socializing, none of the leaders gathered and exchange views. During and after the forum, the various parties had not given any indication that they are willing to come together to fight this round of electoral battle that is looming. The feeling is that in spite of all these agreements and lack of differences, everyone is still trying to keep the status quo and trying to fight the giant on its own.


The current political landscape is akin to a situation where many provision shops selling the same thing are trying to compete with an efficient hypermarket. Instead of pooling and combining resources and getting the economy of scale, these small outfits are trying to see who can battle the giant best and muscle out the rest at the same time.


The end result is the hypermarket gets stronger and more powerful and the provision shops get weaker and ineffective.


I don’t know if the various parties at the forum realised that they share many things in common. As far as I can see, the differences are only in the personality and temperament of the people in charge. From the views expressed at the forum, there is no difference at all in ideology.


Unfortunately, if differences in personality and temperament cannot be set aside for a common cause, then any alternative to the PAP will continue to remain fragmented and ineffective. This would indeed be a disservice to Singapore.


As long as political parties stay in their own cocoons, they will continue to make motherhood statements without being effective in changing things.


Take for example the question of the ISA (Internal Security Act). Everyone wholeheartedly agreed that it should be abolished.


Mr Chiam See Tong summed the mood very eloquently by his stunning declaration “I agree with Dr Chee” (that the ISA should be abolished). It is telling because Mr Chaim and his protégé, Dr Chee Soon Juan, had fallen out almost 20 years ago.


From the look of things, this issue is likely to remain just a little line in the various parties’ election manifestos (or even not at all).


If the parties were so convinced that the ISA should be abolished, why were they not committed enough to call a press conference immediately after the forum to issue a joint press release on this? After all the main stream media and the yahoo news reporters were all around and certainly ready to give audience.


The answer is simple. Truth be told, the bodies have met but the minds have not. Hopefully, the forum would be a step towards the meeting of minds. Otherwise all the wonderful individual manifestos put up by the political parties will not stop the juggernaut from continuing to run the lives of Singaporeans completely in the manner that it has been doing for the last 51 years.


View the original article here