Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Guardian Editorial - Press freedom: The Singapore grip

EditorialThe Guardian, Wednesday 17 November 2010

The country presents itself as a modern liberal democracy yet has an autocratic political culture

Repression is not the route to success. In the end, it will prove its enemy.

Singapore is proud of its place near the top of many international rankings. Its school system is by some measures the world's best. The island state promotes itself as diverse, competitive and cultured – an exciting global hub. But there are two league tables which shame Singapore. The first, compiled by the campaigning group Reporters Without Borders, places the country 136th in the world for press freedom– below Iraq and Zimbabwe. The second is the rate at which Singapore executes convicted criminals: arguably higher, per capita, than any other country in the world.

Singapore presents itself as a modern liberal democracy: it has a parliament, elections, courts, a constitutional right to free speech and the consumerist gloss of capitalism. Its citizens are free to become rich and to travel. Many do both. The country has by any measure succeeded since independence. But its autocratic political culture – overseen by the country's founding father and now official minister mentor Lee Kuan Yew– is highly and needlessly restrictive. The media is largely state-owned. Defamation and contempt laws threaten dissent. The latest victim of these is Alan Shadrake, a British-born writer sentenced yesterday to six weeks in prison and a large fine after being found guilty of contempt of court. His book Once a Jolly Hangman questioned the independence of Singapore's legal system, and its use of the death penalty.

It is depressing that a country as successful as Singapore should feel the need for such restrictions on free speech. Singapore argues that, without them, the balance between the country's Chinese, Malay and Indian populations would be upset. But the reality is that other successful parts of Asia – Hong Kong and Taiwan, for instance – have thrived by extending free speech and the rule of law. Singapore is making itself a less significant place by refusing to give its people the sorts of freedoms that are routine elsewhere.

On a practical level, the decision to prosecute Mr Shadrake was also foolish. His book has had far greater attention because of it, and Singapore's reputation has been harmed. Mr Shadrake is quite right to attack a criminal justice system whose victims are often poor migrant workers. His book was legitimate and – despite the court's claim to the contrary – largely accurate. The suspicion is that the Singapore government resented the exposure of a squalid system of routine executions which sits uneasily with the image it likes to present to the world. Singapore wants to be judged as a first-world nation. It must find the confidence to allow its citizens the freedoms that go with that status. Repression is not the route to success. In the end, it will prove its enemy.


View the original article here

Monday, November 29, 2010

British author found guilty of contempt of court

British author found guilty of contempt of court : SingabloodyporeSingabloodyporeA blog about everything that is dysfunctional in the economically successful city-state of Singapore Singapore's Socio-Political Bloggers A Gecko's Tale A Singapore Odyssey A Writer's Blog: My Life, My Thoughts Aussie Pete Chee Siok Chin's Blog Chemical Generation chung kwong yuen Convex Set Dansong Blog Diary of Singaporean Mind Disgruntled Singaporean e pur si muove Glass Castle Hear ye! Hear ye! Heavenly Sword i-do-not- speak JB Jeyaretnam's Blog Jeff's Blog Malaysiakini (Malaysia) Molly Meek Mr Wang Says So mrbrown L'infantile terrible of Singapore Nofear singapore Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc Pseud onymity Ringisei Blog Sgpolitics .net Singa land Singapore Alternatives Singapore Angle Singapore Daily Singapore Dissident Singapore Election Watch Singapore Indian Voice Singapore Kopi Tok Singapore News Alternative Singapore Patriot Singapore Politics Singapore Rebel Singapore: New Media, Politics & the Law Singaporeans for Democracy The Anti Neo-Democracy Theorist The Death Penalty in Singapore The Ken Tang The Kway Teow Man The Legal Janitor The Moley Prophet The Online Citizen The Police State The Temasek Review The Young Republic Thoughts on Public Policies and Politics Urban Rant Vox Leo - A Singaporean Voice Wayang Party We Believe in Second Chances Winter is Coming Words of the Lion Heart Xenoboy's Blog Yaw Shin Leong @ WP Yawning Bread Zuco's Blog Last updated weblogs LIBEREZLES.NET COMITE DE SOUT...WerwolfDISSIBLOGPolitique et syndicalisme3iwb965jLa Garenne-Colombes : retour ...libertesculturedipandaSupport Adnan and EminlesitĂ©colo francilien November 2010SMTWTFS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9101112131415161718192021222324252627282930 ForumsSammyboy's NEW Coffee Shop Singapore Kopitiam Channel News Asia Sg Forum HardwareZone Google Forum redbeanforum.com Yahoo!Msg Board Find Singapore TOC's online coffeeshop Luntan Zaobao (Chinese) Luntan Zaobao (English) The Political PartiesSingapore Democratic Party People Action Party Singapore Democratic Alliance Workers' Party of Singapore Singapore People's Party National Solidarity Party Malay National Organisation(PKMS) Singapore GE 2006 @ Wikipedia The Reform Party LinksALJAZEERA Reporters Without Borders Z NET (Left Leaning Magazine) Michael Moore Bill Hicks George Monbiot Sister Country Guardian Newspaper ONEWORLD Human Rights Watch - Singapore Nature Society Singapore AWARE Action For AIDS People Like Us Yawning Bread The Think Centre The Socratic Circle GET AROUND NET CENSORSHIP James Gomez Workers Party DISNEYLAND WITH THE DEATH PENALTY Papers on the Death Penalty Singapore's Death Penalty Singapore-Windows Sintercom Singaporeans For Democracy The Optical Little Speck Singapore Review Forum Asia World Social Forum The Big O The Void Deck The Philosopher's Magazine THINK Charles Mackay OPEN DEMOCRACY The Skeptical Inquirer The Why Files Quack Watch Professor Alan Sokal Americans United for the Separation of Church and State Whats New Know Your Enemy, Creationism The Rudicus Report Political Theory Daily Review Index for Free Expression SammyBoy's Cafe Sg Forums International Freedom of Expression eXchange BBC News CNN The New York Times The Economist Christian Science Monitor The Guardian AllAfrica.com Financial Times Inter Press News Service Foreign Policy Foreign Affairs The New Internationalist Reporters Without Borders Committee to Protect Journalists United Nations Oxfam International Human Rights Watch Arab Women Connect International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Comission MADRE Women's Human Rights Net Global Exchange Post Colonial Web Third World Network Focus on the Global South Women's Environment and Development Organization Orient Expat EHRC GoMacau Video CollectionI collect with vodpod Recent comments rill on All in the Family Matilah_Singapura on SINGAPORE: Jehovah's Witnesses imprisoned for... bronah on SINGAPORE: Jehovah's Witnesses imprisoned for... Roland Drum Machine on Singapore - Capitalism without democracy is... Farhan on Activists test Singapore with Biggest Protests... applehong on Two Singapore Democratic Party leaders... TheTruth on Singapore: Executions since December defy... Diesel Jeans on Foreign investments soar in Burma despite... EngageMedia on One Nation Under Lee tye on URGENT -- Yong Vui Kong's appeal Your Ad Here Recent Posts Foreign Office Minister "dismayed" as writer is... British minister 'dismayed' by author's... Guardian Editorial - Press freedom: The... Disgraceful jail sentence for British author in... British author apologises to Singapore judiciary British author found guilty of contempt of court British author faces prison sentence in Singapore Petition appeals for acquittal of British... British author says Singapore book 'fair... Singapore's Death Penalty is On Trial Not Alan... Popular tags Death Penalty Media Protest Myanmar Burma Court Human Rights New Media Singapore Dr Chee Archives 2010-11 2010-10 2010-08 2010-07 2010-06 2010-05 2010-04 2010-03 2010-02 2010-01 All archives Cyberdissidents
follow soci at http://twitter.com OnlinePetitions Upgrading HDB & GE Stop Exploitation of Kids Anti-Death Penalty in Sg Singaporean Blogs BloggerSG.com Anne's Blog Julian I, Am A Comedian Kellog Pencil Shavings Readers Eye MrLim Deus Ex Machina Sarong Party Frens V's Spot cheeky Mr Miyagi The Young Republic Zuco's Blog The Real Question Somewhere between nowhere and just there Crappings of Da Crapster Trompe L'oeil B.O.B. Story of A Dot Tracking my Tainted Faith Everything.s Not As it Seems The Only Promise... Kwentong Tambay Expat@Large Rantings Haven Sheena's Little Fragments... Drifting Round The... Projectmaya Xiaxue Singapore Alternatives Headspace Alleviated Caliginosity Life At Ngee Ann Singapore Legal Mumbo Jumbo Demystified Alfian's Secret Singapore Serf Singasingapore OMEKA NA HURIA Eyes of a Scorpio The Kentang Jeff Yen SerialDeviant Sarong Party Girl sticks and stones Asal Aku Blog What about ALL the good .. Otterman Speaks Yamoo illusio Litmax Campus Moblog Wit and Spit vinzlash Hope? Chemical Generation Singapore Queer Singaporean Bastardisation of the East No Use For a Name Modnoy Blog Womad Singapore Watch Lagu Quran Blog Intellectually Yours Kritik Melayu Singapura Silent Thoughts... SIRC James Seng Malapropos-Wisecracks Autarkic halfcrazed Neuro-Silico Transactions mrs budak's lair Rockson:Talk Rock Qasidah Blog Penulis-Singapura/ SD/KD JB Jeyaretnam's Blog James Gomez Singapore's Anti Death Penalty Campaign The Singapore Election Blog kuncup I Really Don't Know Footprints In The Sand Inspirations and Creative Thoughts Sg Election â??06 Sayoni Speak Singapore Entrepreneurs My Sketchbook The SEAPA Blog Intelligent Singaporean Singapore Dissident blog
WINKsite
Link to Podcast (RSS feed) for this blog Syndicate this site (rss)
Syndicate this site (XML)
« British author faces prison sentence in Singapore |HomePage| British author apologises to Singapore judiciary »

04/11/2010British author found guilty of contempt of courtShare|

VIDEO From Channel 4 News

British author Alan Shadrake has been found guilty of contempt of court and faces a jail sentence after he criticised Singapore's judiciary in a book about the state's use of the death penalty.

http://www.channel4.com/news/british-author-guilty-of-con...

 

 

He was accused by the High Court Judge Quentin Loh of being "guilty of the offence of contempt by scandalising the court".

The 75-year-old author, the judge said, will be given the opportunity to make amends for his comments in the book, but he stopped short of saying if it would help reduce his sentence, which has been deferred until 9 November.

Back in July Shadrake, a freelance journalist, was arrested in Singapore over the contents of his book Once a Jolly Hangman: Singapore Justice in the Dock. He was freed on bail, but could also face charges of defamation.

The judge said in his written judgment that Shadrake had used a "selective background of truths and half-truths, and sometimes outright falsehoods" in the book. He claimed that Shadrake had accused Singapore judges of being influenced by executive and diplomatic pressure.

In Singapore there is no maximum sentence for contempt of court, but Mr Shadrake's lawyer M. Ravi said prosecutors had requested a jail term of up to six months. Contempt of court is punishable by fine, prison or both under Singapore law.

Shadrake told reporters after the hearing: "I'm going to read the judgment with Ravi and we are going to discuss how to go forward."

The death penalty in Singapore is applied for crimes like murder and there is a mandatory death sentence for drug trafficking. Crimes rates in the island nation of five million people, are relatively low compared to other nations around the world.

The judge, Loh said the court had no interest in stifling a debate on the death penalty and is constitutionally bound to protect every citizen’s rights to engage in such debate.

But he said: “when such debate goes beyond the limits of fair criticism, the law will step in.

"It does so not for the dignity of the judges. It does so only to ensure the public's confidence in the administration of justice does not falter."

Critics such as Amnesty International have in the past accused Singapore of using strict defamation laws to stifle dissent.

 

12:35Posted by soci|Permalink| Comments (0)| Trackbacks (0)| Email this| Tags: alan shadrake, death penalty, judiciary, video, singapore

TrackbacksThe URL to Trackback this post is: http://singabloodypore.rsfblog.org/trackback/1647769

 

View the original article here

Sunday, November 28, 2010

British author apologises to Singapore judiciary

(AFP) – 5 hours ago

SINGAPORE — A British author convicted of insulting the Singapore judiciary in a book apologised Tuesday for his actions, saying it had not been his intention to undermine judges.

But prosecutors rejected Alan Shadrake's apology, which came a week after a judge found him guilty of contempt of court over his book about the hanging of criminals in the city-state.

"It was never his intention to undermine the judges or the judiciary," Shadrake said through his lawyer, M. Ravi, during a High Court hearing.

"He would certainly apologise if he had offended the sensitivities of the judiciary."

Contempt of court is punishable in Singapore by imprisonment or a fine, or both, with no maximum limit set on either.

Prosecutors said Shadrake's apology was insincere.

"The apology is half-hearted and hardly an apology. It's insufficient," said Hema Subramanian, the deputy senior state counsel with the Attorney General's chambers.

She called the apology a "tactical ploy to escape the full brunt" of the law and asked the court to sentence him to at least 12 weeks' imprisonment.

Sentencing on Shadrake had been due to go ahead on Tuesday, but was adjourned for a week.

Shadrake's book "Once a Jolly Hangman: Singapore Justice in the Dock" contains a profile of Darshan Singh, the former chief executioner at Singapore's Changi Prison who, according to the author, executed around 1,000 men and women from 1959 until he retired in 2006.

It also features interviews with human rights activists, lawyers and former police officers on cases involving capital punishment.

Copyright © 2010 AFP. All rights reserved.


View the original article here

Saturday, November 27, 2010

British author faces prison sentence in Singapore

Alan Shadrake convicted of challenging integrity of Singapore judiciary in book on state's use of death penaltyJustin McCurryguardian.co.uk, Wednesday 3 November 2010 06.13 GMT

The British author Alan Shadrake is today facing a possible prison sentence after a court in Singapore convicted him of challenging the integrity of the city state's judiciary in a book criticising its use of the death penalty.

Shadrake faces a custodial sentence or a fine – or both – for contempt of court when Singapore's high court sentences him next week.

The Singapore constitution does not specify a maximum penalty for the crime, according to reports, although prosecutors are reported to have demanded a prison sentence of between three and six months and an unspecified fine.

The judge, Quentin Loh, said he was giving 75-year-old Shadrake "a final opportunity to make amends".

The author, who has refused to apologise, said after the ruling that he would "work out how to do this and satisfy the court".

The case has cast further doubt on Singapore's commitment to freedom of expression. Shadrake's lawyer, M Ravi, insisted his client had not intended to scandalise the conservative state's "hypersensitive" judiciary, adding that comments critical of the criminal justice system were "fair criticism".

The case was brought in response to Shadrake's book, Once a Jolly Hangman: Singapore's Justice in the Dock, which accuses courts of bowing to diplomatic and economic pressure in deciding how to dispense justice.

It also accuses them of favouring the wealthy and abusing the law to suppress political opponents.

The book includes a profile of a former chief executioner and interviews with human rights activists, lawyers and former police officers.

According to Amnesty International, Singapore, with a population of five million, has one of the world's highest per capita execution rates, having put more than 400 people to death over the past two decades.

Loh said: "This is a case about someone who says, among other things, the judges in Singapore are not impartial ... and are influenced by political and economic situations and biased against the weak and the poor."

Last month, Singapore's attorney general's office described comments in Shadrake's book as "especially pernicious", adding that they "cannot possibly come within any reasonable notion of fair criticism".

The book, which was published in Malaysia, where Shadrake is based, is reportedly not banned in Singapore, but sellers and distributors will have to seek legal advice before releasing it.

Shadrake, whose passport has been confiscated by the authorities, was released on bail. He was arrested in July while promoting the book in Singapore, and is also being investigated for possible criminal defamation – a crime carrying a prison sentence of up to two years.

Alan Shadrake outside the High Court yesterday. His book criticises the death penalty in Singapore A British ...A British author was today convicted of contempt by the High Court in Singapore over a book he wrote which criticised the republic's death ...SINGAPORE—Singapore's High Court on Wednesday found a UK author in contempt of court for statements in his book on the city-state's death ...Has the world gone mad? I have always wanted to start a piece with the columnist's favourite cliche. This week, though, it seems surprisingly apposite. ...Telegraph.co.uk - ?Nov 3, 2010?British writer Alan Shadrake has been found guilty of contempt of court for criticising Singapore's judiciary in a book on the city-state's use of the death ...A Singapore court has found a British author Alan Shadrake, guilty of insulting the judiciary in a book he wrote on the death penalty. ...SINGAPORE — Singapore's Supreme Court found a 75-year-old British author, Alan Shadrake, guilty of insulting the judiciary in a book he wrote on the hanging ...SINGAPORE, Nov 3 (Bernama) - A British writer who wrote a book on the death penalty in Singapore was today found guilty by the High ...The British author Alan Shadrake is today facing a possible prison sentence after a court in Singapore convicted him of challenging the integrity of the ...A Singapore court has found the UK author Alan Shadrake guilty of insulting the Singapore judiciary in a book he wrote about the death penalty. ...British author Alan Shadrake was convicted of contempt of court for his book challenging the integrity and ...SINGAPORE: British author Alan Shadrake has been found guilty of contempt of court for 11 ...British author Alan Shadrake faces a possible prison sentence after being convicted by the High Court in Singapore over a book criticising the island's use ...Australia Network News - ?7 hours ago?A Singapore court has convicted a British author of contempt of court for criticising the judiciary in a book on the death penalty in Singapore. ...MobyLives has been covering the trial of British author and journalist, Alan Shadrake, (here, here and here) who was arrested for “insulting the Singapore ...Mainichi Daily News - ?8 hours ago?SINGAPORE (Kyodo) -- A Singapore court on Wednesday convicted a British author of contempt of court for criticizing the city-state's judiciary in a book on ...CisionWire (press release) - ?17 hours ago?(Washington, DC) - Singapore's conviction of author Alan Shadrake for contempt of court will further stifle freedom of expression and legitimate criticism ...SINGAPORE, Nov. 3 (UPI) -- The British author of a book criticizing Singapore's use of the death penalty faces a prison term there for contempt of court, ...Amnesty International UK - ?19 hours ago?Singapore's conviction of the author Alan Shadrake, for contempt of court will further stifle freedom of expression and legitimate criticism of the ...British author Alan Shadrake has been convicted in Singapore for publishing passages which the court finds untrue and contemptuous of the ...UK Today News - ?20 hours ago?Alan Shadrake, a writer of UK has been found guilty of abusing (in a way), judiciary in Singapore in one of his books. Shadrake's, 'Once a Jolly Hangman ...A Singaporean verdict against British author Alan Shadrake has been watched closely around the world, in particular by Yale University in the US, ...Index On Censorship - ?Nov 3, 2010?British author Alan Shadrake has been found guilty of insulting Singapore's judiciary in a book he wrote about the city state's use of the death penalty. ...By PA Media Lawyer British journalist Alan Shadrake was today convicted of contempt by the High Court in Singapore over a book he wrote about the island ...(RTTNews) - Singapore's High Court on Wednesday found British author Alan Shadrake guilty of questioning integrity of the judiciary in a book he wrote about ...A British freelance journalist and author has been found guilty of contempt of court for criticising Singapore's judiciary in a recent book, according to ...Aliran Monthly - ?Nov 2, 2010?By admin, on 2 November 2010 Reporters Without Borders have launched an international petition calling for the release of British author and journalist Alan ...Alan Shadrake, 75, was yesterday found guilty of insulting Singapore's judiciary in his book, Once A Jolly Hangman: Singapore Justice In ...SINGAPORE - British author and journalist Alan Shadrake (picture) has been found guilty of contempt of court for his book on the death penalty ...

View the original article here

Friday, November 26, 2010

British minister 'dismayed' by author's Singapore jail term

SINGAPORE (AFP) — A minister has said he is "dismayed" by the prison sentence handed to a British author convicted by a Singapore court of insulting the city-state's judiciary.

Foreign office minister Jeremy Browne said in comments posted on the website of the British High Commission in Singapore that author Alan Shadrake's views on the judicial system should be covered by the right to freedom of expression.

The High Court of the island republic on Tuesday imposed a six-week jail term on 76-year-old Shadrake for insulting the judiciary by publishing a book critical of executions there.

The freelance journalist was also fined 20,000 Singapore dollars (15,000 US) following his conviction for contempt of court. He remains free pending an appeal.

"The government attaches importance to freedom of expression around the world," Browne said in remarks seen on the website Friday.

"I am therefore dismayed that Mr Shadrake has been charged, convicted and sentenced to six weeks in jail in Singapore for expressing his personal views on the legal system."

Browne added that the commission "would continue to call on all countries, including Singapore, to recognise the right to freedom of expression as set out in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights".

On Thursday, Shadrake said through his lawyer that he was filing an appeal to overturn the conviction, which stemmed from allegations made in his book "Once a Jolly Hangman: Singapore Justice in the Dock".

Singapore's Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA) issued a sharp rebuttal to Browne's comments, saying it was "surprised" he had raised the issue and the case had nothing to do with freedom of expression.

"The Ministry of Foreign Affairs is surprised that a British minister has commented on the matter, which is not about freedom of expression or Singapore-UK relations, but about the integrity of Singapore's judicial system," a ministry spokesman said.

"The British government should understand that Singapore has the right to enforce its own laws to protect the reputation of our judiciary and judicial system, as well as other key public institutions."

However, both Browne and the MFA said Shadrake's case was unlikely to affect bilateral ties, with the British minister scheduled to make an introductory visit to Singapore in December.


View the original article here

Wednesday, November 24, 2010

Disgraceful jail sentence for British author in Singapore

The jailing of 76-year-old British author Alan Shadrake in Singapore is, quite simply, a disgrace. It confirms that there is no freedom of expression in the city-state island.

Convicted of contempt of court, he must serve six weeks and pay a fine of SGD$20,000 (£9,600). He also faces separate charges of criminal defamation, which are punishable by a maximum of two years in prison and a hefty fine.

All the charges relate to his book, which argues that the Singaporean judiciary is not impartial in its application of the death penalty.

There is a black irony in juxtaposing his conviction with the title of his book, Once a jolly hangman: Singapore's justice in the dock.

I agree with Index on Censorship's chief executive John Kampfner who says that the "sentence once again shows Singapore's desperate difficulties in dealing with criticism and free expression."

When finding Shadrake guilty of contempt of court earlier this month, Singapore's high court judge, Quentin Loh, said the book contained "half-truths and selective facts; sometimes outright falsehoods."

In an interview two weeks ago with The Guardian, Shadrake admitted to one minor inaccuracy in his book, but insisted the rest was "devastatingly accurate".

Shadrake, who suffers from an irregular heartbeat and a serious colonic illness, did offer a qualified apology last week, but stood by the claims made in his book.

As Justin McCurry points out, Shadrake's trial has reignited debate over Singapore's use of contempt laws to stifle dissent and punish journalists deemed to have insulted the authorities.

Shadrake enjoyed what's been called "a rich and varied career" as a journalist and author. Born in Essex, he spent a lengthy period in the 1960s as a Fleet Street correspondent in West Berlin.

In the 1970s, he turned to writing books, having initial sales success with an authorised biography of Bruce Lee. After moving to Los Angeles in the mid-1980s, he quickly became a fixture at Ye Olde King's Head pub in Santa Monica.

From 1990 to 2003 he wrote the popular but contentious Shooting From The Lip column for the Santa Monica-based paper that serves the large British expat community in California, the British Weekly.

He later moved on to Las Vegas, where he enjoyed continuing success as a freelance writer for various publications across the world.

He moved to Singapore after falling in love with a Singapore woman who he met on a press junket.


View the original article here